|
Spanish experts
see no Serbian genocide in Kosovo
by Pablo Ordaz
Commentary by Jared Israel (9-27-99)
1
2 3 4
6
p.5
Investigation? or
Inquisition?
Some people ask: are
you saying Serbs are incapable of committing atrocities? No, as
with all populations, some Serbian people are probably capable of
committing atrocities. But to go from this general possibility to
the charge that the Serbian armed forces systematically killed Albanian
civilians (while publicly arguing for multi-ethnic unity and indeed
arming many Albanians against the KLA) is to go quite a distance.
Traversing it requires something: proof.
American legal theory
says a person is innocent until proven guilty. Implicit in this
approach is the notion that criminal investigation should be conducted
by disinterested parties with a goal of finding out if there
has been a crime and discovering the truth, not in proving
a case to destroy some enemy.
Aside from whether this
standard is actually applied in the U.S. legal system (a highly
debatable point) shouldn't we insist it be applied when dealing
with alleged mass crimes possibly implicating a government and an
entire people? Or should such investigations be launched only as
needed to justify NATO policy? Should guilt then be decided by a
hostile US press with government officials making prejudicial statements
before the fact? Should the evidence be the testimony of
'witnesses' supplied by the US side in a vicious war, 'witnesses'
who testify in secret, 'witnesses' who are never cross-examined
by the accused?
The use of these Inquisitorial
methods of proof rebounds, proving that NATO (that is, the US government)
and the media are trying to railroad the Serbian people.
Every time an accusation
is made, two parties go on trial: the accused and the accuser. For
if an accusation can be shown to be false, then the question must
be asked: was it made with malicious intent? Was it perhaps cooked
up to divert attention from and/or justify some other crime, some
greater crime? Some crime, perhaps, committed by the accuser? (see
note 4 at end)
The Spanish forensic
scientists and policemen quoted in El Pais have done us all
a service. By denying NATO's charges they have indicted NATO. In
doing so they have risked NATO's wrath - and their careers - to
tell the truth. Their decency gives one hope.
(See note 3 for analyses
of questionable NATO/US government 'mass graves' claims)
***
NOTES
Note 1: First hand
reports of KLA terror
* For an interview with
the leader of the Jewish community in Pristina, Kosovo, click here:
Driven
from Kosovo: Jewish Leader Sees NATO Complicity or go to: http://www.emperors-clothes.com/interviews/ceda.htm
* For an interview with
Kosovo Albanians who led opposition to the KLA and have been forced
out of Kosovo by threat of death, click here:Kosovo
Albanians - The Other Side or go to: http://www.emperors-clothes.com/interviews/alban.htm
Next
Page Previous Page
|